Home / Fishing Tackle Shop / Thorpe Underwood Meadows
Thorpe Underwood Meadows

Thorpe Underwood Meadows

Back
Thorpe Green Ln, York YO26 9TA, UK
Fishing pond
7 (22 reviews)

Thorpe Underwood Meadows is a small, informal fishing complex that appeals mainly to anglers looking for relaxed sessions with friends rather than a highly commercialised venue. Set around a couple of ponds with simple pegs and basic facilities, it has built a reputation as a budget-friendly place to enjoy a casual day of fishing, especially for those who value atmosphere and freedom over luxury. For some visitors it offers exactly what they want – somewhere to set up the bivvy, chat, have a drink and cast a line – while others find the rough edges and limited upkeep frustrating.

This fishery is often described as an unfussy, no-frills spot where the priority is simply getting rods in the water. Anglers come here with modest expectations of the fishing, focusing more on time away from home than on chasing specimen fish. Those who are used to modern, manicured commercial venues with manicured banks, well-marked pegs and comprehensive facilities may find Thorpe Underwood Meadows surprisingly basic, but for fishermen who appreciate a more old-fashioned style of water it can feel disarmingly straightforward. The low cost for day and night sessions is a strong draw for groups who want to enjoy an affordable social over their rods.

Fishing opportunities and stock

The venue is centred around small lakes that suit anglers who enjoy general coarse fishing rather than highly technical, match-style sport. Feedback suggests that catches can be hit and miss, with some sessions producing very little and others delivering a few solid fish. One visitor who fished the second lake over a 24-hour session noted that only a single fish was landed across that time, which underlines the unpredictable nature of the sport here. This is not the place to visit if your only goal is to fill a keepnet or work through a big head of carp; a patient, relaxed mindset is essential.

Despite the modest stocking levels, there are some decent fish to be had for those willing to put the time in. Anglers mention the presence of grass carp and other coarse species, giving the water enough variety for a casual session. Expectations, however, need to be realistic: you are unlikely to find the densely stocked, high-yield environment that characterises many modern commercials. For some anglers, that is part of the appeal; they enjoy the quieter banks, the sense of space and the opportunity to focus on watercraft instead of constant bites. For others, especially those prioritising consistent action, the fishing can feel slow.

Techniques used here tend to mirror those at many small coarse venues. Standard carp and coarse methods with method feeders, simple ledgering and float fishing can all produce results on the right day. Many anglers arrive equipped with their usual carping gear – alarms, bivvies and all the trimmings – planning a laid-back session rather than a tightly structured match. The lack of intense pressure compared with more popular commercials can make it a more peaceful setting for trying rigs and baits without feeling crowded, though this still depends heavily on who else is on the bank during your visit.

Atmosphere and type of angler

Thorpe Underwood Meadows attracts a particular type of customer: anglers who see fishing as a social event as much as a sporting challenge. Reviews repeatedly highlight that this is a place where people go with mates, sit around the pegs, enjoy a few drinks and have an easygoing time. One visitor described it as ideal if you want to spend time with friends, have a laugh and even listen to the owner playing the bagpipes in the background. That picture won’t appeal to every fisherman, but for some it’s the main reason to choose this venue over more polished but stricter commercials.

The owner’s presence is a distinctive part of the experience. Several comments mention a strong personality, with some guests remembering him fondly as an entertaining character who adds to the informal feel, while others report heated exchanges and raised voices when rules or expectations weren’t aligned. This split in opinion matters for potential visitors: those who are comfortable with direct communication and a slightly eccentric atmosphere may enjoy it, while those seeking a highly professional, customer-service-driven environment might prefer somewhere else.

Groups looking for a low-cost overnight session often see Thorpe Underwood Meadows as a practical option. Night fishing is considered affordable, which appeals to younger anglers and those who simply want to spend time outdoors without spending heavily. That said, the same relaxed environment can mean that not every group treats the venue with equal respect, and this has sometimes led to noise, late-night disturbances and friction between visitors. For anglers who want quiet banks, this can be a downside, particularly if they value early starts and undisturbed sleep.

Facilities, maintenance and comfort

One of the most consistent criticisms of Thorpe Underwood Meadows relates to the state of the facilities. Visitors comment that the toilets are in poor condition and in need of serious attention. For families, mixed groups or anyone planning a long stay on site, this is a significant drawback; basic hygiene and comfort are important at any fishery, and when those standards slip it can overshadow the advantages of affordable fishing. The lack of clear, structured maintenance routines is noticeable in more than one review.

Around the lakes, anglers have pointed out that the banks and general surroundings could benefit from a tidy-up. Some describe the site as “in need of a clean-up” and suggest that modest investment in bank work, vegetation management and peg improvements would make a real difference. In its current state, Thorpe Underwood Meadows feels more like a rough-and-ready local water than a carefully managed commercial venue. For some this adds a sense of authenticity; for others it comes across as neglect.

There are also comments about nearby accommodation and residents, including reports of disturbances caused by individuals living in a lodge by the water. Instances of arguments, late-night noise and even the involvement of the police are mentioned in feedback, which raises concerns for visitors seeking a calm, family-friendly environment. While such incidents may not be everyday occurrences, they are important to consider if you are planning to bring children or if a peaceful atmosphere is a top priority for your fishing trips.

Strengths for casual and social anglers

Despite its shortcomings, Thorpe Underwood Meadows has several qualities that appeal to a particular audience. The affordability of both day and night sessions makes it accessible to anglers who might not be able to justify the higher prices of more famous fisheries. Groups of friends can set up together, share a long session and enjoy the feeling of being away from routine. For those who treat fishing as a chance to sit back, chat, have a drink and take things at their own pace, this venue can deliver what they need.

The informal approach to rules and the relaxed atmosphere can be attractive to anglers who feel constrained by the tight regulations imposed at many larger, busier fisheries. Here, the culture is more about mutual understanding and common sense, even if that occasionally leads to disagreements. Some visitors enjoy the sense that they are regulars sharing a familiar, slightly scruffy water rather than customers at a highly commercial operation. The presence of characterful touches – such as the owner’s bagpipe playing – reinforces that feeling of individuality, which some anglers remember fondly.

For novice anglers or those returning to fishing after a break, the lack of pressure can be helpful. Without large crowds or strict peg allocations, people can take their time setting up, adjusting rigs and learning at their own speed. Parents introducing older children or teenagers to coarse fishing may appreciate the ability to keep everyone together on the bank, provided they are comfortable with the occasionally boisterous atmosphere. The key is to recognise that this is a relaxed, slightly rough venue and to decide whether that matches your expectations.

Limitations and points to consider

For many potential visitors, the limitations of Thorpe Underwood Meadows are as important as its strengths. Anglers who prioritise high catch rates, immaculate facilities and a strictly controlled environment are likely to be disappointed. Reports of dirty toilets, untidy banks and intermittent disturbances from nearby residents paint a picture of a fishery that has not fully kept pace with the standards set by more modern commercial venues. Those issues can be especially off-putting for families with young children or anyone who values a clean, orderly setting.

There are also concerns about inconsistency in the way issues are handled on site. While some see the owner as friendly and welcoming, others describe him as confrontational when problems arise, such as collecting firewood or misunderstandings regarding payment. For first-time visitors, this unpredictability can be unsettling. Clear, visible rules, better communication and a more measured approach to conflict would likely improve the experience for a broader range of anglers.

Catching fish here can require patience, and anglers should not expect instant results. If you are travelling a long distance specifically for the fishing, it may be worth weighing up whether the potential rewards justify the trip. Locals who understand the water, know the better pegs and accept the venue’s quirks tend to be more forgiving, while visitors coming in with expectations set by highly stocked commercials are more likely to be critical when the fishing is slow.

Suitability for families and beginners

When it comes to suitability for families, Thorpe Underwood Meadows divides opinion. On one hand, the low cost and small scale of the lakes can seem ideal for a relaxed family day out by the water, with plenty of space to set up and keep an eye on children. On the other hand, reports of late-night noise, arguments and the occasional presence of drunk adults on site make it less appealing for those who want a completely calm and child-focused environment.

Beginners and casual anglers can still find value here, especially if accompanied by more experienced friends who know what to expect. The key is preparation: bring everything you need, including your own sanitation supplies and plenty of food and drink, and be ready for an experience that is more like traditional, informal pond fishing than a polished commercial complex. If comfort and pristine surroundings matter more to you than cost, other fisheries in the region may be a better fit.

For families with older teenagers who are used to basic camping or outdoor conditions, Thorpe Underwood Meadows can provide a straightforward introduction to nights under the bivvy, bite alarms and the rhythms of a 24-hour session. As always, a realistic understanding of the venue’s character is crucial. This is somewhere to enjoy casual fishing and shared time, not necessarily to chase trophy fish or expect hotel-level comfort.

Overall impression for potential visitors

Overall, Thorpe Underwood Meadows stands out as a rough-and-ready local fishery that suits anglers looking for a cheap, social session rather than a finely tuned angling experience. Its strengths lie in affordability, the freedom to relax with friends and the individuality of a water that has not been heavily commercialised. For those who enjoy a bit of character, can live with basic facilities and are happy to treat catching fish as a bonus rather than a guarantee, it can provide an enjoyable break from routine.

The drawbacks are equally clear: variable maintenance, poor toilet standards and occasional disturbances around the site mean it falls short of what many modern anglers expect. Mixed feedback about the management style adds another layer of unpredictability. Anyone considering a visit should weigh these factors carefully against their own priorities. If you value comfort, cleanliness and consistently good fishing above all else, you may decide to look elsewhere. If, instead, you are after low-cost time on the bank with friends and are comfortable with an informal, sometimes rough-around-the-edges environment, Thorpe Underwood Meadows could still hold some appeal.

Other businesses you might be interested in

View All